Activity 1, Classification Drill
1. X → Pure substance (element, specifically aluminium,
Al).
Sharp, fixed MP at 660°C confirms pure substance. Excellent
conductivity as a solid indicates metallic bonding → must be a
metal element (most metal compounds don't conduct as solids).
2. Y → Mixture. Melting over a 17°C range
(45–62°C) is the key signal, pure substances never melt over a
range. Non-conductivity is consistent with many substance types,
so it doesn't help narrow down further.
3. Z → Most likely an element (nickel, Ni).
Evidence: (1) Sharp, fixed MP at 1455°C → pure substance, not a
mixture. (2) Excellent conductivity as a solid → metallic
bonding → strongly suggests an elemental metal. Most ionic or
covalent compounds with metals do not conduct as solids.
Activity 2, Error Spotting
Response 1, Error: Student A attributed the
broad melting range to measurement error. A 25°C span (40–65°C)
is far too large to be explained by thermometer inaccuracy.
Correct response: The substance is a mixture. A
broad melting range is chemical evidence of variable composition, different components begin to melt at different temperatures,
producing a gradual transition rather than a sharp plateau.
Measurement error would produce a deviation of ±1–2°C at most,
not 25°C.
Response 2, Error: Student B claimed compounds
retain reduced versions of element properties ("sodium still
retains some reactivity").
Correct response: Compounds do not retain any
properties of their constituent elements. When Na and Cl₂ react,
entirely new ionic bonds form between Na⁺ and Cl⁻, creating a
new lattice structure. NaCl is not reactive with water, it
simply dissolves. No trace of sodium's explosivity or chlorine's
toxicity survives in the compound.
Response 3, Error: Student C concluded "metal"
from the conductivity in solution data.
Correct response: The substance is an ionic
compound. Metals generally conduct as solids (delocalised electrons). A
substance that doesn't conduct as a solid but does conduct in
solution indicates an ionic compound, solid ions are
immobilised in the lattice, but dissolving releases mobile
Na⁺/Cl⁻ (or equivalent) ions that can carry charge.
❓ Multiple Choice
Sharp, fixed MP is the most reliable
single indicator. Colour, conductivity, and solubility vary
across both types.
A 23°C melting range confirms mixture. Pure substances always melt at a single, precise temperature.
NaCl's ionic lattice with strong
electrostatic forces accounts for its high MP. B (averaging
rule) doesn't apply to compounds. C is false (many compounds
melt below their elements). D is wrong, NaCl is a compound, not
a mixture.
Melting point (sharp or gradual) + a
second independent property is the gold standard. Single tests
or qualitative observations are insufficient.
Substance X melts over a 40°C range →
mixture. W, Y, Z all have sharp, fixed MPs → pure substances.
Short Answer Model Answers
Q6 (3 marks): A pure substance has a sharp,
fixed MP, on a heating curve, temperature holds constant at a
flat plateau during the solid → liquid transition (1 mark). A
mixture melts over a temperature range, the heating curve shows
a gradual upward slope rather than a flat plateau during
transition (1 mark). The width of the melting range reflects the
degree of impurity, a wider range indicates more mixed
composition; a narrower range indicates closer to pure (1 mark).
Q7 (4 marks): When Fe and S react chemically,
new bonds form between the atoms, producing FeS with a
completely different structure (1 mark). Iron is magnetic and
reacts with dilute acid to release hydrogen; sulfur is a brittle
yellow non-metal that is not magnetic, yet FeS is non-magnetic
and reacts with dilute acid to release hydrogen sulfide (H₂S), a
toxic gas (1 mark). These properties belong to neither starting
element, they arise from the new bonding and structure of the
compound (1 mark). This confirms that a compound is a new
substance whose properties must be determined experimentally,
not inferred from its elements (1 mark). Safety:
adding dilute acid to a metal sulfide releases toxic hydrogen
sulfide, so this is a teacher demonstration with ventilation
only, never an open student practical.
Q8 (5 marks): The claim is correct for Liquid A
but incorrect for Liquid B (1 mark). Liquid A boils at exactly
100°C regardless of sample size, this is consistent with pure
water, which has a fixed, characteristic BP of 100°C at standard
pressure; the consistency across sample sizes confirms uniform
composition (1 mark). Liquid B boils between 100–108°C and the
BP varies by sample, this is a mixture, not pure water (1
mark). A fixed BP is a defining property of a pure substance; a
BP that changes with sample or concentration indicates dissolved
solutes (1 mark). Liquid B is most likely an aqueous salt
solution, dissolved ions elevate the boiling point (boiling
point elevation), and the exact BP depends on concentration,
explaining the observed variation (1 mark).