Activity 1
1. CaF₂ will have a higher MP. Ca²⁺ has a charge of +2 while K⁺ has +1; F⁻ and Br⁻ both have −1, but the Ca²⁺/F⁻ combination produces stronger electrostatic attraction (higher charge on Ca²⁺ → higher lattice energy). Additionally, F⁻ is smaller than Br⁻, meaning ions in CaF₂ are closer together, further increasing the attraction. Both factors (higher charge on cation + smaller anion) raise the lattice energy → higher MP for CaF₂.
2. When MgCl₂ melts, the ionic lattice breaks down and Mg²⁺ and Cl⁻ ions become free to move independently in the liquid. When a voltage is applied, Mg²⁺ ions (positive) migrate toward the negative electrode (cathode) and Cl⁻ ions (negative) migrate toward the positive electrode (anode). This movement of charged particles constitutes an electric current, hence excellent conductivity.
3. X: ionic compound, high MP, no solid conductivity but excellent molten conductivity, hard and brittle. Y: covalent molecular compound, low MP (180°C), no conductivity in any state, soft and waxy. Z: metallic element, very high MP (1538°C = iron), excellent conductivity as both solid and liquid, malleable.
Activity 2
A: Copper conducts as a solid because it has a sea of delocalised electrons that are free to move throughout the metallic lattice at all times, no lattice disruption is needed. NaCl does not conduct as a solid because its charge carriers (Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ions) are fixed in the ionic lattice and cannot move. Both conduct as liquids: liquid copper still has delocalised electrons; molten NaCl has freed ions that can now move.
B: Glucose dissolves in water as intact polar molecules (C₆H₁₂O₆), not as ions. There are no charged particles in the glucose solution, water molecules interact with the glucose molecules via hydrogen bonding, but no ionisation occurs. Since conductivity requires mobile charge carriers (ions or free electrons), and dissolved glucose has neither, it does not conduct electricity even in solution.
❓ Multiple Choice
Ions fixed in lattice = correct ionic explanation. A is wrong (there ARE ions; the issue is they can't move). B and D are factually wrong.
NaCl (±1) vs MgO (±2) = massive charge difference → massive MP difference. A, C, D all involve ±1 compounds with small size differences → small MP differences.
High MP + hard/brittle + no solid conductivity + conducts dissolved = all ionic hallmarks.
Higher charges → stronger Coulomb attraction → higher lattice energy → higher MP. The correct causal chain.
Water's polarity attracts and separates ions (hydration). Mobile hydrated ions carry charge. No electrons or neutral atoms are involved.
Short Answer Model Answers
Q6 (3 marks): In NaCl, Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ions are arranged in a regular, repeating 3D pattern, each Na⁺ is surrounded by 6 Cl⁻ and each Cl⁻ is surrounded by 6 Na⁺ (1 mark). The lattice is held together by strong electrostatic forces (ionic bonds) between oppositely charged ions acting in all directions simultaneously (1 mark). No discrete molecules exist because each ion is attracted to all its nearest neighbours, not to one specific partner, the entire crystal is one giant extended structure in which the formula NaCl simply represents the simplest whole-number ratio of ions (1 mark).
Q7 (4 marks): Solid aluminium (Al) conducts electricity because it has a sea of delocalised electrons that are free to move throughout the metallic lattice, electrons are the charge carriers (1 mark). Solid Al₂O₃ does not conduct because Al³⁺ and O²⁻ ions are fixed in the rigid ionic lattice and cannot move, no mobile charge carriers are present (1 mark). Liquid aluminium conducts because the metallic structure is maintained in the molten state, delocalised electrons remain mobile (1 mark). Molten Al₂O₃ conducts because the lattice has broken down, Al³⁺ and O²⁻ ions are now free to move and carry charge; the charge carriers in this case are ions, not electrons (1 mark).
Q8 (4 marks): MgO has a very high melting point (2852°C) because Mg²⁺ and O²⁻ carry charges of ±2, producing very strong electrostatic attraction between ions and a very high lattice energy (1 mark). In comparison, NaCl (MP 801°C) has ions with charges of only ±1, the electrostatic attraction is roughly four times weaker (applying Coulomb's Law: force ∝ charge₁ × charge₂), so much less energy is needed to disrupt the NaCl lattice (1 mark). To use a substance as a refractory material, it must not melt at operating temperatures, MgO's 2852°C MP means it remains solid in furnaces, kilns, and industrial reactors that operate at temperatures far exceeding those where NaCl would have already melted (1 mark). Additionally, the strong lattice makes MgO chemically and thermally stable under extreme conditions, it does not readily decompose or react with other materials at high temperature (1 mark).