Year 11 Chemistry Module 2 Inquiry Question 1 ⏱ ~45 min Lesson 13 of 20

Limiting Reagents
& Theoretical Yield

Most real reactions don't have reactants in perfect stoichiometric proportions — one runs out first and stops the reaction. Identifying which reactant is the limiting reagent, and calculating the maximum possible yield, are among the most tested skills in HSC Chemistry.

🚦
📐

Limiting Reagent Method

Step 1: Balance the equation
Step 2: n = m ÷ MM for BOTH reactants
Step 3: Divide each n by its coefficient → compare
Step 4: Smaller value = limiting reagent (LR)
Step 5: Calculate yield using LR moles only
⚠️ Never identify the LR by comparing masses or moles alone — you must divide each by its coefficient first. A substance with fewer moles might still be in excess if its coefficient is smaller. The comparison only works after dividing by coefficients.

Know

  • Limiting reagent (LR) — the reactant that runs out first
  • Excess reagent — the reactant remaining when reaction stops
  • Theoretical yield — maximum product from LR
  • LR identified by smallest n ÷ coefficient value

Understand

  • Why the reaction stops when the LR is consumed
  • Why comparing raw moles alone is insufficient
  • Why theoretical yield is calculated from the LR only
✅ Can Do

Skills

  • Identify the LR from masses of two reactants
  • Calculate theoretical yield of any product from the LR
  • Calculate mass of excess reagent remaining after reaction
Printable worksheet

Download this lesson's worksheet

Use the PDF for classwork, homework or revision. It includes key ideas, activities, questions, an extend task and success-criteria proof.

Think First

When you make sandwiches, having more bread than fillings means you'll run out of filling first — the filling limits how many sandwiches you can make. In chemistry, how would you decide which of two reactants "runs out first" and stops the reaction? What information would you need beyond just the masses given?

Type your initial thoughts below:

Record your ideas in your workbook.

✏️ Record your ideas in your workbook
Key Terms
MoleThe SI unit for amount of substance; contains exactly 6.022 × 10²³ particles.
Avogadro's Number6.022 × 10²³ — the number of particles in one mole of a substance.
Molar MassThe mass of one mole of a substance, measured in g/mol.
Limiting ReagentThe reactant that is completely consumed first, limiting the amount of product formed.
Empirical FormulaThe simplest whole-number ratio of atoms in a compound.
Molecular FormulaThe actual number of atoms of each element in a molecule of a compound.

Misconceptions to Fix

Wrong: Gases have no mass because they float.

Right: Gases have mass; their density is just much lower than solids and liquids.

🚦

Limiting and Excess Reagents

When two reactants are mixed in non-stoichiometric amounts, one will be completely consumed before the other. The reactant that runs out first is the limiting reagent (LR) — it limits the amount of product that can form. The other reactant is the excess reagent — some of it remains unreacted when the reaction stops.

Analogy: Making sandwiches requires 2 slices of bread and 1 filling. If you have 10 slices of bread and 3 fillings, you can only make 3 sandwiches — filling is the limiting reagent. 4 slices of bread are left over (excess).

How to Identify the Limiting Reagent

The key step is dividing each reactant's moles by its coefficient in the balanced equation. This normalises the amounts — it tells you how many "reaction-units" of each reactant you have. The reactant with the smaller normalised value is the limiting reagent.

The comparison:
For each reactant: calculate n ÷ coefficient
The smaller value → limiting reagent
The larger value → excess reagent

Example: 2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O
n(H₂) = 3 mol → 3 ÷ 2 = 1.5
n(O₂) = 2 mol → 2 ÷ 1 = 2.0
H₂ has the smaller value (1.5 < 2.0) → H₂ is the limiting reagent
LIMITING REAGENT COMPARISON — Example: 2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O with 3 mol H₂ and 2 mol O₂ 0 0.5 1.0 2.0 n ÷ coefficient (reaction-units) LR value = 1.5 H₂ 3 mol ÷ 2 = 1.5 LIMITING REAGENT ⚠ Runs out first O₂ 2 mol ÷ 1 = 2.0 consumed (1.5) excess left over
Interactive: Limiting Reagent Simulator

Theoretical Yield

The theoretical yield is the maximum mass of product that can form, calculated from the moles of the limiting reagent. Once you have identified the LR, the yield calculation is just the standard 4-step stoichiometry method applied to the LR.

Mass of Excess Reagent Remaining

You can also calculate how much of the excess reagent is left over after the reaction. Find how much of the excess reagent is consumed (using the LR moles and the ratio), then subtract from the original amount.

Excess remaining:
n(excess consumed) = n(LR) × coeff(excess) ÷ coeff(LR)
n(excess remaining) = n(excess original) − n(excess consumed)
m(excess remaining) = n(excess remaining) × MM(excess)
LIMITING REAGENT — IDENTIFICATION METHOD Reactant A m(A) given Reactant B m(B) given n=m÷MM n=m÷MM n(A) mol n(B) mol ÷ coeff(A) ÷ coeff(B) value₁ value₂ Compare which is smaller? SMALLER → LIMITING ← LARGER → EXCESS

Worked Example 1 — H₂ + O₂ (1:1 ratio after normalising)

Basic LR
5.00 g of H₂ reacts with 32.0 g of O₂ to form water. Identify the limiting reagent and calculate the theoretical yield of H₂O. 2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O. (H = 1.008, O = 15.999)
  1. 1
    Balance — done. Coefficients: H₂ = 2, O₂ = 1, H₂O = 2
  2. 2
    n for both reactants
    n(H₂) = 5.00 ÷ 2.016 = 2.480 mol
    n(O₂) = 32.0 ÷ 31.998 = 1.000 mol
  3. 3
    Divide by coefficient and compare
    H₂: 2.480 ÷ 2 = 1.240
    O₂: 1.000 ÷ 1 = 1.000
    O₂ has the smaller value (1.000 < 1.240) → O₂ is the LIMITING REAGENT
  4. 4
    Theoretical yield from LR (O₂). Ratio O₂:H₂O = 1:2
    n(H₂O) = 1.000 × (2÷1) = 2.000 mol
    MM(H₂O) = 18.015; m(H₂O) = 2.000 × 18.015 = 36.0 g
✓ LRO₂✓ Yieldm(H₂O) = 36.0 g

Worked Example 2 — Na + Cl₂ (non-1:1 ratio)

Non-1:1 Coefficients
10.0 g of Na reacts with 20.0 g of Cl₂. Identify the limiting reagent and calculate the theoretical yield of NaCl. 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl. (Na = 22.990, Cl = 35.453)
  1. 1
    Balanced. Coefficients: Na = 2, Cl₂ = 1
  2. 2
    n for both reactants
    n(Na) = 10.0 ÷ 22.990 = 0.4350 mol
    n(Cl₂) = 20.0 ÷ 70.906 = 0.2820 mol
  3. 3
    Divide by coefficient and compare
    Na: 0.4350 ÷ 2 = 0.2175
    Cl₂: 0.2820 ÷ 1 = 0.2820
    Na has the smaller value (0.2175 < 0.2820) → Na is the LIMITING REAGENT
  4. 4
    Theoretical yield from LR (Na). Ratio Na:NaCl = 2:2 = 1:1
    n(NaCl) = 0.4350 × 1 = 0.4350 mol
    MM(NaCl) = 58.443; m(NaCl) = 0.4350 × 58.443 = 25.4 g
✓ LRNa✓ Yieldm(NaCl) = 25.4 g

Worked Example 3 — Excess reagent remaining

Mass of Excess
From WE2: 10.0 g Na + 20.0 g Cl₂ → NaCl. Na is the LR. Calculate the mass of Cl₂ remaining after the reaction.
  1. 1
    n(Cl₂) consumed by n(Na) = 0.4350 mol. Ratio Na:Cl₂ = 2:1
    n(Cl₂ consumed) = 0.4350 × (1÷2) = 0.2175 mol
  2. 2
    n(Cl₂ remaining)
    n(Cl₂ remaining) = 0.2820 − 0.2175 = 0.0645 mol
  3. 3
    m(Cl₂ remaining)
    m(Cl₂) = 0.0645 × 70.906 = 4.57 g
✓ Cl₂ remaining4.57 g of Cl₂ unreacted

Worked Example 4 — 2Al + 3Cl₂ → 2AlCl₃

Full LR + Yield + Excess
10.8 g of Al reacts with 21.3 g of Cl₂. (a) Identify the LR. (b) Find theoretical yield of AlCl₃. (c) Find mass of excess reagent remaining. (Al = 26.982, Cl = 35.453)
  1. 1
    Balanced: 2Al + 3Cl₂ → 2AlCl₃. Coefficients: Al=2, Cl₂=3
  2. 2
    n for both reactants
    n(Al) = 10.8 ÷ 26.982 = 0.4003 mol
    n(Cl₂) = 21.3 ÷ 70.906 = 0.3004 mol
  3. 3
    Divide by coefficient — compare
    Al: 0.4003 ÷ 2 = 0.2002
    Cl₂: 0.3004 ÷ 3 = 0.1001
    Cl₂ has smaller value (0.1001 < 0.2002) → Cl₂ is the LIMITING REAGENT
  4. 4
    (b) Yield from Cl₂. Ratio Cl₂:AlCl₃ = 3:2
    n(AlCl₃) = 0.3004 × (2÷3) = 0.2003 mol
    MM(AlCl₃) = 26.982+3(35.453) = 133.34; m = 0.2003×133.34 = 26.7 g
  5. 5
    (c) Al consumed and remaining. Ratio Cl₂:Al = 3:2
    n(Al consumed) = 0.3004 × (2÷3) = 0.2003 mol
    n(Al remaining) = 0.4003 − 0.2003 = 0.2000 mol
    m(Al remaining) = 0.2000 × 26.982 = 5.40 g
✓ LRCl₂✓ AlCl₃26.7 g✓ Al excess5.40 g
⚠️

Common Mistakes

Picking the LR based on smaller mass or smaller moles alone
In 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl, a student with 0.44 mol Na and 0.28 mol Cl₂ might say "Cl₂ is the LR because it has fewer moles." But you must divide by coefficients first: Na = 0.44 ÷ 2 = 0.22, Cl₂ = 0.28 ÷ 1 = 0.28. Na is actually the LR. Skipping the division step gives the wrong reagent in any non-1:1 reaction.
✓ Fix: Always perform n ÷ coefficient for every reactant before comparing. Never compare raw moles or masses. Write out the comparison explicitly.
Using the excess reagent's moles to calculate yield
Once the LR is identified, all product yield calculations must use the LR's moles. Using the excess reagent's moles gives a larger, incorrect theoretical yield. This is particularly dangerous because the number seems plausible — it's just wrong.
✓ Fix: After identifying the LR, cross out the excess reagent's moles. Proceed from LR moles only for all yield calculations.
Forgetting to subtract consumed moles when finding excess remaining
The mass of excess reagent remaining requires two steps: (1) calculate how much was consumed using the LR and the ratio, (2) subtract from the original amount. Students who skip step 1 and just report the original mass of the excess reagent are wrong — some was consumed before the LR ran out.
✓ Fix: n(excess remaining) = n(excess original) − n(excess consumed). Always calculate n(consumed) first using the LR moles and the balanced equation ratio.

📓 Copy Into Your Books

🚦 LR Identification Steps

  • 1. Balance equation
  • 2. n = m ÷ MM for both reactants
  • 3. Divide each n by its coefficient
  • 4. Smaller quotient = limiting reagent
  • 5. Use LR moles for all yield calcs

📦 Theoretical Yield

  • Always calculated from LR moles only
  • Apply mole ratio: LR → product
  • Then m = n × MM(product)
  • = max possible product if 100% efficient

♻️ Excess Remaining

  • n(consumed) = n(LR) × coeff(E) ÷ coeff(LR)
  • n(remaining) = n(original) − n(consumed)
  • m(remaining) = n(remaining) × MM

⚠️ The Key Traps

  • Never use mass or raw moles to pick LR
  • MUST divide by coefficient first
  • After LR found — use LR moles only
  • Excess remaining ≠ original excess mass

📝 How are you completing this lesson?

🚦 Activity 1 — Limiting Reagent Drill

Identify LR and Calculate Yield

Show the full comparison (n ÷ coefficient) for every problem. State which is the LR before calculating yield.

1 4.00 g of Fe reacts with 4.00 g of S. Fe + S → FeS. Identify the LR and calculate theoretical yield of FeS. (Fe = 55.845, S = 32.06)

n(Fe) = 4.00 ÷ 55.845 = 0.07164; ÷1 = 0.07164 n(S) = 4.00 ÷ 32.06 = 0.1248; ÷1 = 0.1248 Fe has smaller quotient → Fe is the LR n(FeS) = 0.07164 × 1 = 0.07164 mol MM(FeS) = 87.91; m(FeS) = 0.07164 × 87.91 = 6.30 g

2 6.00 g of H₂ reacts with 32.0 g of O₂. 2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O. Identify the LR and calculate m(H₂O). (H = 1.008, O = 15.999)

n(H₂) = 6.00 ÷ 2.016 = 2.976; ÷2 = 1.488 n(O₂) = 32.0 ÷ 31.998 = 1.000; ÷1 = 1.000 O₂ has smaller quotient → O₂ is the LR n(H₂O) = 1.000 × (2÷1) = 2.000 mol; m = 2.000 × 18.015 = 36.0 g

3 From Q2 above — calculate the mass of H₂ remaining after the reaction.

Ratio O₂:H₂ = 1:2; n(H₂ consumed) = 1.000 × (2÷1) = 2.000 mol n(H₂ remaining) = 2.976 − 2.000 = 0.976 mol m(H₂ remaining) = 0.976 × 2.016 = 1.97 g

4 5.60 g of N₂ reacts with 1.50 g of H₂. N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃. Identify the LR. (N = 14.007, H = 1.008)

n(N₂) = 5.60 ÷ 28.014 = 0.1999; ÷1 = 0.1999 n(H₂) = 1.50 ÷ 2.016 = 0.7440; ÷3 = 0.2480 N₂ has smaller quotient (0.1999 < 0.2480) → N₂ is the LR

Show full working for all questions:

Complete in workbook.

✏️ Complete in workbook
📊 Activity 2 — Data Analysis

Industrial Reaction Analysis

A laboratory runs four reactions with the amounts shown. For each, identify the LR, calculate theoretical yield of the named product, and calculate the mass of excess reagent remaining. Show all working below.

ReactionAmounts givenFind
2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO m(Mg) = 4.86 g
m(O₂) = 3.20 g
LR, m(MgO), m(excess remaining)
4NH₃ + 5O₂ → 4NO + 6H₂O m(NH₃) = 8.50 g
m(O₂) = 16.0 g
LR, m(NO)

Mg=24.305, O=15.999, N=14.007, H=1.008

Show full working for both reactions:

Complete in workbook.

✏️ Complete in workbook
Revisit — Think First

At the start of this lesson, you thought about how you would decide which of two reactants "runs out first" in a chemical reaction and what information you would need beyond just the masses.

The key insight is that you cannot compare masses directly — you must convert to moles and then divide by each reactant's coefficient. The reactant with the smallest "moles ÷ coefficient" value is the limiting reagent, because it is the first to be fully consumed. The theoretical yield of any product must be calculated from the limiting reagent alone.

Reflect: how did your initial thinking compare to what you've learned?

Write a reflection in your workbook.

✏️ Write a reflection in your workbook
MC

Multiple Choice

5 random questions from a replayable lesson bank — feedback shown immediately

📝

Extended Questions

ApplyBand 3

6. 5.40 g of Al reacts with 10.65 g of Cl₂. 2Al + 3Cl₂ → 2AlCl₃. (a) Show which reactant is the limiting reagent using the correct comparison method. (b) Calculate the theoretical yield of AlCl₃. (Al = 26.982, Cl = 35.453) 5 MARKS

Show full comparison and all steps:

Answer in workbook.

✏️ Answer in workbook
AnalyseBand 4

7. 16.0 g of CH₄ reacts with 64.0 g of O₂. CH₄ + 2O₂ → CO₂ + 2H₂O. (a) Identify the limiting reagent. (b) Calculate the theoretical yield of CO₂. (c) Calculate the mass of the excess reagent remaining after the reaction. (C=12.011, H=1.008, O=15.999) 6 MARKS

Show all working for a, b, and c:

Answer in workbook.

✏️ Answer in workbook
EvaluateBand 5

8. A student says: "I mixed 10 g of each reactant, so neither one can be limiting — they're in equal amounts." Explain why this reasoning is incorrect and describe the correct method for identifying the limiting reagent. 3 MARKS

Write in full sentences:

Answer in workbook.

✏️ Answer in workbook
AnalyseBand 4

9. 14.0 g of N₂ is mixed with 6.00 g of H₂ for the Haber process: N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃. (a) Identify the limiting reagent using the correct method. (b) Calculate the theoretical yield of NH₃. (c) Calculate the mass of the excess reagent remaining after the reaction. (N = 14.007, H = 1.008) 6 MARKS

Show full comparison and all steps for b and c:

Answer in workbook.

✏️ Answer in workbook
EvaluateBand 5

10. In the reaction 4NH₃ + 5O₂ → 4NO + 6H₂O, a student is given 17.0 g of NH₃ and 48.0 g of O₂. She correctly identifies the limiting reagent and calculates the theoretical yield of NO. Another student argues: "We should use whichever reagent gives the larger amount of product, because that's the maximum." Evaluate this second student's reasoning and explain what is wrong with it. (N = 14.007, H = 1.008, O = 15.999) 4 MARKS

Calculate both possible yields, then explain the error in reasoning:

Answer in workbook.

✏️ Answer in workbook

✅ Comprehensive Answers

📊 Activity 2 — Data Table Answers

Reaction 1 (2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO):

n(Mg) = 4.86÷24.305 = 0.2000; ÷2 = 0.1000 n(O₂) = 3.20÷31.998 = 0.1000; ÷1 = 0.1000

Equal quotients — both consumed exactly (stoichiometric ratio). No excess remains.

n(MgO) = 0.2000 × 1 = 0.2000 mol; MM(MgO)=40.304; m(MgO) = 0.2000×40.304 = 8.06 g

Reaction 2 (4NH₃ + 5O₂ → 4NO + 6H₂O):

n(NH₃) = 8.50÷17.031 = 0.4992; ÷4 = 0.1248 n(O₂) = 16.0÷31.998 = 0.5001; ÷5 = 0.1000 O₂ has smaller quotient (0.1000 < 0.1248) → O₂ is LR Ratio O₂:NO = 5:4; n(NO) = 0.5001×(4÷5) = 0.4001 mol MM(NO) = 30.006; m(NO) = 0.4001×30.006 = 12.0 g

❓ Multiple Choice

1. B — H₂: 1.20÷3 = 0.40; N₂: 0.50÷1 = 0.50. H₂ has the smaller quotient → LR. Options A and C use the wrong comparison method.

2. C — Cl₂: 0.30÷3 = 0.10; Al: 0.30÷2 = 0.15. Cl₂ has the smaller quotient → LR. Option D has the division backwards (wrong which is smaller).

3. A — Theoretical yield uses LR moles × mole ratio to product. Using excess reagent moles gives a falsely high answer.

4. D — 35.7 g. n(H₂) = 4.00÷2.016 = 1.984 mol (LR); ratio H₂:H₂O = 1:1; n(H₂O) = 1.984; m = 1.984×18.015 = 35.7 g.

5. B — 0.26 g. n(H₂) = 4.00÷2.016 = 1.984 mol (LR). n(O₂ consumed) = 1.984×(1÷2) = 0.992 mol. n(O₂ initial) = 32.0÷31.998 = 1.000 mol. n(O₂ remaining) = 1.000−0.992 = 0.008 mol. m(O₂ remaining) = 0.008×31.998 = 0.26 g.

6. D — The student's conclusion (Fe is limiting) happens to be correct, but her method is wrong. Comparing raw moles without dividing by coefficients is invalid. The correct comparison is n÷coefficient: n(Fe)=5.58÷55.845=0.09992÷2=0.04996; n(Cl₂)=7.10÷70.906=0.1001÷3=0.03337. Cl₂ has the smaller quotient, making Cl₂ the actual limiting reagent — the opposite of what the student concluded.

7. A — This question tests whether students can work backwards and recognise when a problem has no solution. n(Cl₂) = 5.00÷70.906 = 0.07052 mol; ratio Cl₂:AlCl₃ = 3:2; n(AlCl₃) = 0.07052×(2÷3) = 0.04701 mol; m(AlCl₃) = 0.04701×133.34 = 6.27 g. Only 6.27 g of AlCl₃ can form from 5.00 g of Cl₂, regardless of how much Al is added. Option A correctly identifies this impossibility.

📝 Short Answer Model Answers

Q6 (5 marks):

(a) n(Al) = 5.40÷26.982 = 0.2001 mol; ÷2 = 0.1001 n(Cl₂) = 10.65÷70.906 = 0.1502 mol; ÷3 = 0.05006 Cl₂ has smaller quotient (0.0501 < 0.1001) → Cl₂ is the limiting reagent (b) Ratio Cl₂:AlCl₃ = 3:2; n(AlCl₃) = 0.1502×(2÷3) = 0.1001 mol MM(AlCl₃) = 133.34; m(AlCl₃) = 0.1001×133.34 = 13.4 g

Q7 (6 marks):

(a) n(CH₄) = 16.0÷16.043 = 0.9973 mol; ÷1 = 0.9973 n(O₂) = 64.0÷31.998 = 2.000 mol; ÷2 = 1.000 CH₄ has smaller quotient (0.9973 < 1.000) → CH₄ is the LR (b) Ratio CH₄:CO₂ = 1:1; n(CO₂) = 0.9973 mol; MM(CO₂)=44.009; m = 0.9973×44.009 = 43.9 g (c) n(O₂ consumed) = 0.9973×(2÷1) = 1.995 mol; n(O₂ remaining) = 2.000−1.995 = 0.005 mol m(O₂ remaining) = 0.005×31.998 = 0.16 g

Q8 (3 marks): Equal masses do not mean equal moles, because different substances have different molar masses. Even if the masses are identical, the number of moles of each reactant (n = m ÷ MM) will differ unless their molar masses happen to be equal. Furthermore, even equal moles does not guarantee stoichiometric equivalence — the coefficients in the balanced equation determine the ratio in which reactants are consumed. The correct method is to calculate moles of each reactant, divide each by its coefficient in the balanced equation, and identify the reactant with the smaller quotient as the limiting reagent.

Q9 (6 marks):

(a) n(N₂) = 14.0÷28.014 = 0.4998 mol; ÷1 = 0.4998 n(H₂) = 6.00÷2.016 = 2.976 mol; ÷3 = 0.9921

N₂ has smaller quotient (0.4998 < 0.9921) → N₂ is the limiting reagent

(b) Ratio N₂:NH₃ = 1:2; n(NH₃) = 0.4998×2 = 0.9996 mol MM(NH₃) = 17.031; m(NH₃) = 0.9996×17.031 = 17.0 g (c) Ratio N₂:H₂ = 1:3; n(H₂ consumed) = 0.4998×3 = 1.499 mol n(H₂ remaining) = 2.976−1.499 = 1.477 mol; m = 1.477×2.016 = 2.98 g

Q10 (4 marks):

n(NH₃) = 17.0÷17.031 = 0.9982; ÷4 = 0.2496 → NH₃ quotient n(O₂) = 48.0÷31.998 = 1.500; ÷5 = 0.3000 → O₂ quotient

NH₃ has smaller quotient → NH₃ is the LR

If NH₃ is LR: ratio NH₃:NO = 4:4 = 1:1; n(NO) = 0.9982; m = 0.9982×30.006 = 29.9 g (correct) If O₂ is used incorrectly: ratio O₂:NO = 5:4; n(NO) = 1.500×(4÷5) = 1.200; m = 1.200×30.006 = 36.0 g (incorrect — too large)

The second student's reasoning is wrong because using the excess reagent overestimates how much product can form. The excess reagent has "too much" relative to the LR; the reaction stops when the LR runs out, leaving excess reagent unused. The theoretical yield must be calculated only from the limiting reagent, which gives the lower (correct) answer.

☄️
Asteroid Blaster

Blast the Correct Answer

Defend your ship by blasting the correct answers for Limiting Reagents & Theoretical Yield. Scores count toward the Asteroid Blaster leaderboard.

Play Asteroid Blaster →

Mark lesson as complete

Tick when you've finished all activities and checked your answers.