Activity 1, Alkyne and Alkane Practice
1. Ethyne full halogenation: Step 1: HC≡CH + Br2 → CHBr=CHBr (1,2-dibromoethene, dihaloalkene). Step 2: CHBr=CHBr + Br2 → CHBr2CHBr2 (1,1,2,2-tetrabromoethane, tetrahaloalkane). No catalyst; room temperature; fume cupboard. Both steps decolourise bromine water.
2. Propyne hydration: CH3C≡CH + H2O → CH3COCH3 (propanone). Product class: ketone (not alcohol). Conditions: dilute H2SO4 AND Hg²⁺ catalyst, ~60°C, heated glassware, fume cupboard.
3. But-2-yne partial hydrogenation (Lindlar): CH3C≡CCH3 + H2 → CH3CH=CHCH3 (but-2-ene, specifically cis isomer). The supported palladium catalyst is deliberately deactivated with lead compounds and quinoline, so it stops after one H2 addition.
4. Methane + Cl2: CH4 + Cl2 → CH3Cl + HCl. UV light is an energy source, not a catalyst, it provides energy to break the Cl-Cl bond (homolysis), generating Cl radicals that initiate the chain. It is electromagnetic radiation (energy), not matter, and is not regenerated.
Activity 2, Identify and Classify
A. Compound P (C5H8) = alkyne (CnH2n-2 for n=5; two sequential Br₂ additions confirm two pi bonds). Full halogenation product: C5H8Br4 (tetrahaloalkane, 4 Br atoms added across the two pi bonds).
B. The reaction requires BOTH dilute H2SO4 and Hg²⁺, omitting H2SO4 means the reaction does not proceed. Hg²⁺ is needed as a Lewis acid catalyst that activates the C≡C toward nucleophilic attack by water. H2SO4 provides the acidic medium required. Without both, the activation barrier cannot be overcome.
C. The claim is incorrect. Limited oxygen supply gives incomplete combustion, producing toxic carbon monoxide (CO) and/or soot (C) instead of CO2. CO is far more immediately dangerous than CO2. It binds haemoglobin 250× more strongly than O2, blocking oxygen transport and causing toxicity. While less CO2 is produced, the incomplete combustion products are a more acute health hazard.
D. The student is correct. Ethyne (HC≡CH) is the special case, it is symmetrical and terminal. When H2O adds, the enol intermediate is vinyl alcohol (CH2=CHOH), which tautomerises to ethanal (CH3CHO). The carbonyl ends up at C1, making it an aldehyde. Ethyne is the only alkyne that gives an aldehyde; all other alkynes give ketones.
Multiple Choice Answers
1. Correct response: Propyne + excess HBr (two steps, Markovnikov each time). Step 1: H to C1 (terminal, 1H), Br to C2 → CH3CBr=CH2 (2-bromopropene). Step 2: CH3CBr=CH2 + HBr, C1 (=CH2) has 2H, Markovnikov H to C1, Br to C2 (already has Br) → CH3CBr2CH3 = 2,2-dibromopropane (geminal dihalide). Option D would be halogenation (Br₂), not hydrohalogenation (HBr).
2. Correct response: A catalyst is a substance (matter) that lowers activation energy and is regenerated. UV light is energy (electromagnetic radiation), not matter. It is absorbed in the initiation step to break Cl-Cl bonds. Options A and D incorrectly apply the definition of a catalyst to a non-substance.
3. Correct response: But-1-yne hydration: H to C1 (terminal, more H), OH to C2 (Markovnikov). Enol intermediate (but-1-en-2-ol) instantly tautomerises to butan-2-one (CH3COCH2CH3), a ketone. Option B (butan-2-ol) would only form if the enol did not tautomerise. Terminal alkynes beyond ethyne give ketones, not aldehydes; only ethyne gives an aldehyde.
4. Correct response: Two sequential Br₂ additions (consuming 2 equivalents) confirms two pi bonds → alkyne. Option A alone cannot distinguish alkyne from alkene (both decolourise Br₂). Options B and C describe reactions shared by both compound classes.
5. Correct response: C: 3 → 3CO2. H: 8 → 4H2O. O right: 6+4=10 → O2 = 5. C3H8 + 5O2 → 3CO2 + 4H2O ✓. Option B has wrong O2 coefficient. Option C gives incomplete combustion product.
Short Answer Model Answers
Q1 (3 marks): The Lindlar catalyst is palladium supported on calcium carbonate and deliberately deactivated with lead compounds and quinoline [1]. It catalyses syn addition of the first equivalent of H2 across a triple bond to produce a cis alkene, but does not continue reducing the resulting C=C bond to an alkane [1]. A standard Ni, Pd, or Pt catalyst continues hydrogenation to the fully saturated alkane [1].
Q2 (4 marks): Propyne: CH3C≡CH + H2O → CH3COCH3 (propanone, a ketone). Conditions: dilute H2SO4 + Hg²⁺, ~60°C [1]. Propene: CH3CH=CH2 + H2O → CH3CH(OH)CH3 (propan-2-ol, an alcohol). Conditions: H3PO4, 300°C, high pressure [1]. The products belong to different functional group classes [1] because propene hydration produces a stable alcohol directly; propyne hydration initially produces a vinyl alcohol (enol) which is thermodynamically unstable and spontaneously tautomerises to propanone (ketone), so the OH group does not persist [1].
Q3 (5 marks): The bromine water test alone is not sufficient [1]. Both alkenes and alkynes decolourise bromine water; an alkane does not. The test can separate the alkane from the other two, but cannot distinguish alkene from alkyne on decolourisation alone [1]. A complete testing protocol: (1) Add Br₂(aq) to each compound. The alkane will not decolourise. The alkene and alkyne will both decolourise [1]. (2) For the two that decolourise: add a second equivalent of Br₂(aq). The alkyne will decolourise again (second pi bond reacts); the alkene will not (it has been fully consumed in step 1) [1]. (3) To confirm the alkane: react with Cl₂ or Br₂ under UV light, a haloalkane + HX product is formed by substitution, confirming the saturated compound is an alkane [1].