Activity 1
1. Coagulation with alum belongs in particle removal. Al³⁺ hydrolyses to Al(OH)₃, which adsorbs suspended particles and helps them form larger flocs.
2. Activated carbon filtration belongs in removal of remaining fine particles and some dissolved organics. Its large surface area helps adsorb compounds affecting water quality.
3. Reverse osmosis belongs in dissolved salt removal. It uses a membrane to separate water from salts, but it has a significant energy cost.
Activity 2
1. Chloramines are a strong choice because they generally form fewer DBPs than free chlorine while still providing a residual disinfectant in distribution, although they act more slowly.
2. UV is a strong option when rapid disinfection is needed but long-term residual protection is not essential, because UV leaves no residual disinfectant in the water.
3. Reverse osmosis is the main process for desalination. The major concern is its high energy demand and therefore higher operating cost.
Multiple Choice
Coagulation: destabilises suspended particles so larger flocs can form.
Active species: HOCl is the more active disinfectant species.
pH effect: higher pH shifts chlorine chemistry toward OCl⁻, so disinfection becomes less effective.
Precursor removal: removing organics helps reduce DBP formation such as trihalomethanes.
Method trade-off: chloramines can lower THM formation compared with free chlorine and provide residual protection, but disinfect more slowly.
Short Answer Model Answers
Q1 (4 marks): Major drinking water treatment stages include coagulation, flocculation, sedimentation, filtration and disinfection. In coagulation, alum helps destabilise fine suspended particles. Flocculation brings these together into larger flocs. Sedimentation allows the flocs to settle. Filtration through media such as sand, gravel and activated carbon removes remaining particles and some dissolved organics. Disinfection then reduces pathogen risk before the water enters supply.
Q2 (5 marks): In coagulation, alum provides Al³⁺ ions that hydrolyse to form Al(OH)₃. This colloidal aluminium hydroxide adsorbs suspended particles and helps them combine into flocs that can later settle. In chlorination, chlorine reacts with water to form HOCl and HCl. HOCl is the active disinfectant species. HOCl is also in equilibrium with OCl⁻, and as pH rises a greater proportion becomes OCl⁻. Because OCl⁻ is a weaker disinfectant, higher pH reduces disinfection effectiveness.
Q3 (5 marks): For a large Sydney distribution network, free chlorine provides strong disinfection and leaves a residual, but it can form more DBPs when organic matter is present. Chloramines are often a better compromise when the goal is to maintain residual protection while reducing DBP formation. However, chloramines disinfect more slowly than free chlorine. UV is useful because it avoids chlorine-based DBPs, but it leaves no residual disinfectant in the network, so by itself it is less suitable for long pipe systems. Overall, a strategy that reduces organics first and then uses chloramines for residual protection is often the most suitable balance for this scenario.