Ssciencelab
0 0 0 XP Lvl 1
KJ
📖 Lesson 11 ⏱ ~30 min Year 7 · Unit 4 ⚡ +85 XP

First Astronomers: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Sky Knowledge

Long before telescopes, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples were watching, recording and explaining the sky. For tens of thousands of years, knowledge of the stars, the Sun and the Moon has been carefully observed and passed down through story, song and Lore. Some Nations, such as the Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land, hold detailed Cultural Knowledges connecting the Moon to the rising and falling of the tides. In this lesson you will explore this knowledge respectfully, then compare it with the mainstream scientific explanation of the Moon phases and tides. You will see that both come from careful observation of the sky over very long periods.

Today's hook: The Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land have, over thousands of years, built up detailed Knowledge linking the Moon to the tides. They observed that the position and phase of the Moon match the pattern of high and low tides. Modern science explains the same link using the Moon's gravity. Two very different ways of knowing, both built from patient observation of the sky, and both agree that the Moon and the tides are connected. How can that be?
0/5QUESTS
Warm-up
Think First
+5 XP each

Q1 · Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples have observed the sky for tens of thousands of years. What kinds of useful things do you think people could learn by carefully watching the Moon and the stars over a very long time?

Q2 · In earlier lessons you learned that the Moon is linked to the tides. Do you think two different cultures, watching the same sky on opposite sides of the world, could each notice this link on their own? Why or why not?

2
Learning objectives
What you'll master
3 areas

● Know

  • That Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples are among the world's first astronomers, holding Cultural Knowledges of astronomy built over tens of thousands of years (NESA SC4-OTU-01)
  • That many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Nations, such as the Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land, hold detailed Knowledge linking the Moon to the tides
  • The mainstream scientific explanation: the Moon's gravity causes the tides, and Moon phases come from the relative positions of the Sun, the Earth and the Moon

● Understand

  • How knowledge of the sky was carefully observed and passed on through oral tradition, story, song and Lore
  • How both Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Knowledges and modern science recognise a real, predictable link between the Moon and the tides (NESA SC4-OTU-01)
  • Why these are complementary ways of knowing, both built from careful, repeated observation, rather than a case of "myth versus fact"

● Can do

  • Describe, respectfully, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Knowledge of the Moon and tides, naming a specific Nation
  • Explain the scientific account of Moon phases and how the Moon affects the tides
  • Compare the two accounts and explain what they have in common
True or false? Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples have observed and recorded the sky for tens of thousands of years, making them among the world's first astronomers.
3
The big idea
The World's First Astronomers
+5 XP

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples are among the world's first astronomers. For tens of thousands of years, Peoples across this continent and the Torres Strait have watched the night sky, recorded its patterns, and used that knowledge in daily life. This is the NSW syllabus dot point you are studying today: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples' Cultural Knowledges of astronomy (SC4-OTU-01).

It is important to be accurate and respectful here. There is no single "Aboriginal belief" about the sky. There are many distinct Nations, each with its own language, Country and Cultural Knowledges. When we name a Nation, we attribute the knowledge to that Nation.

  • Knowledge of the sky was, and still is, passed on through oral tradition, story, song and Lore, rather than written books.
  • This knowledge comes from careful observation repeated over a very long time, which is the same way science builds reliable knowledge.
  • Sky knowledge had practical uses, such as knowing when food was ready, when to travel, and how the tides would behave.

We will look only at knowledge that is well established and publicly shared. Some Cultural Knowledge is sacred or held only by certain people, and it is not ours to retell. Treating knowledge with respect is part of learning about it properly.

Three of these describe how Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander sky knowledge works. Tap the odd one out.
4
Cultural Knowledge
Yolngu Knowledge of the Moon and the Tides
+5 XP

The Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land, in the Northern Territory, hold well-documented Cultural Knowledge connecting the Moon to the tides. Living on Country beside the sea, Yolngu People observed over many generations that the rising and falling of the tides matches the position and phase of the Moon in the sky.

This is detailed, practical Knowledge. People who live by the coast need to know when the water will be high and when it will be low, for fishing, for gathering shellfish, and for travelling safely. By watching how the tides changed as the Moon moved through its phases, Yolngu People built up a reliable understanding of when high and low tides would come.

This Knowledge was developed over many thousands of years and passed down through story, song and Lore. We present it here respectfully as Cultural Knowledge of a specific Nation. It is a clear example of the same idea you met earlier in this unit: that knowledge of the sky comes from patient, repeated observation.

Which Nation holds the well-documented Cultural Knowledge described here, linking the Moon to the tides?
The scientific account
How Science Explains Moon Phases and Tides
+5 XP

In earlier lessons you met the mainstream scientific explanation. It is worth recalling here so you can compare it with the Cultural Knowledge above.

  • Moon phases: the Moon does not make its own light; it reflects sunlight. As the Moon orbits the Earth, we see different amounts of its lit side. The phase depends on the relative positions of the Sun, the Earth and the Moon. This gives us new Moon, first quarter, full Moon and last quarter.
  • Tides: the Moon's gravity pulls on the Earth's oceans, raising a bulge of water that we feel as a high tide. As the Earth rotates, places move into and out of these bulges, giving roughly two high and two low tides each day.
  • Spring and neap tides: at new Moon and full Moon, the Sun and Moon line up, so their pulls add together and we get the largest tides, called spring tides. At the quarter Moons, the Sun and Moon pull at right angles, so the tides are smallest, called neap tides.

So in the scientific account, the Moon's phase tells us where the Moon is compared with the Sun, and that position is exactly what decides how strong the tides are. The phase of the Moon and the size of the tide are connected.

Scientific model: at full Moon the Sun, Earth and Moon line up and the tidal bulges are largest (spring tide) Sun Earth Moon Sun, Earth and Moon in a line: pulls add up, so tides are largest (spring tide) tidal bulge tidal bulge
Complete the sentences about the scientific explanation. Choose the correct word for each blank.

In the scientific account, the tides are caused mainly by the Moon's ___. The phase of the Moon depends on the relative positions of the Sun, the Earth and the ___. The largest tides, called spring tides, happen at new Moon and ___ Moon, when the Sun and Moon line up.

6
Comparing the accounts
Two Ways of Knowing the Moon and Tides
+5 XP

The syllabus asks you to compare Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Knowledge of the Moon and tides with the mainstream scientific explanation. The most important point is this: both recognise a real, predictable link between the Moon's phase and the tides.

They are different in how they are expressed and passed on, but they are not opposites. This is not a case of "myth versus fact". Both are the result of careful, repeated observation of the sky over long periods of time.

  • What they share: both agree the Moon and the tides are connected, and both can be used to predict when high and low tides will come. Both were built up by watching the sky carefully over a long time.
  • How they differ: Yolngu Knowledge is held within Culture and passed on through story, song and Lore. The scientific account is written down and explains the link using the idea of the Moon's gravity. Each fits the way that knowledge system works.

A good way to think about it is that these are two different but complementary ways of knowing. They look at the same sky, notice the same real pattern, and each builds reliable, useful knowledge from it. This ties back to the big idea of this whole unit: science, and Cultural Knowledge, are built from observation over time.

Two ways of knowing the Moon-tide link: Yolngu Cultural Knowledge and the scientific explanation both recognise the same real connection Yolngu Cultural Knowledge Observed over thousands of years on Country Passed on through story, song and Lore Scientific explanation Built from measured observations over time Explained using the Moon's gravity = Both recognise the same real link: the Moon's phase and the tides are connected
Match each statement to the account it best describes.
  • Yolngu Cultural Knowledge
  • Scientific explanation
  • Shared by both accounts
  • True of neither account
  • Passed on through story, song and Lore on Country
  • Explains the tides using the idea of the Moon's gravity
  • Recognises a real, predictable link between the Moon and the tides
  • Claims the Moon has no effect on the tides at all
More sky Knowledges
Astronomy Across Many Nations
+5 XP

The Moon and tides are just one example. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples across the continent and the Torres Strait hold a wealth of well-documented astronomy Knowledges. Here are a few that are publicly shared, each attributed to the Peoples who hold them.

  • The Emu in the Sky: many Aboriginal Nations recognise a great emu shape formed by the dark dust clouds of the Milky Way, not by stars. Its position through the year is linked to the behaviour of real emus, such as when they lay their eggs.
  • Tagai of the Torres Strait: Torres Strait Islander Peoples hold detailed Knowledge of Tagai, a great figure made of stars, which is used to mark the seasons and to guide planting, fishing and sailing.
  • Seasonal star calendars: the appearance of certain stars at certain times of year tells Peoples when seasons are changing and when particular foods are ready. This is careful, long-term sky observation put to practical use.

These examples show the same theme as the Moon and tides: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander astronomy is detailed, practical and built from patient observation over a very long time. We only share what is public and established, and we attribute it to the Peoples who hold it.

Which statement best and most respectfully describes Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander astronomy?
Predict then reveal+8 XP
1 · Predict
2 · Reveal
3 · Compare

The Yolngu People connected the Moon to the tides through thousands of years of observation. Modern science explains the same link using the Moon's gravity. Predict: how could two very different ways of knowing, on opposite sides of the world, both end up agreeing that the Moon and the tides are connected?

50%
Reflect
Revisit your thinking
reflect

At the start you wrote about what people could learn by watching the sky over a long time. Now write an improved, complete answer.

Your answer must: (1) state that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples are among the world's first astronomers; (2) describe, respectfully, the Yolngu Knowledge of the Moon and tides, naming the Nation; (3) compare it with the scientific account and explain what they share. Use the words observation, Cultural Knowledge, Moon and tides.

1
Quick check
Which statement about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander astronomy is most accurate?
+10 XP
2
Quick check
The Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land hold well-documented Knowledge about which link?
+10 XP
3
Quick check
In the mainstream scientific explanation, what causes the ocean tides?
+10 XP
4
Quick check
When the Sun, the Earth and the Moon line up at new Moon and full Moon, we get the largest tides. What are these called?
+10 XP
5
Quick check
What is the best way to describe how Yolngu Knowledge and the scientific account of the Moon and tides relate?
+10 XP
Short answer · explain in your own words
Show your reasoning
3 questions
Recall Core 3 marks

Q1. Describe, respectfully, the Yolngu People's Cultural Knowledge of the Moon and the tides. In your answer, name the Nation and say how this Knowledge was developed and passed on. (3 marks)

Recall Core 3 marks

Q2. Explain the mainstream scientific account of how the Moon affects the tides, and how the phase of the Moon is linked to the size of the tides. (3 marks)

Evaluate Core 4 marks

Q3. Compare the Yolngu Cultural Knowledge and the scientific account of the link between the Moon and the tides. Give one way they are similar and one way they differ, and explain why both can be seen as reliable. (4 marks)

0
From the lesson
Answers

Answers

MCQ 1

C. Many distinct Nations hold their own detailed Cultural Knowledges, built from observation over tens of thousands of years. There is no single shared belief, the knowledge is far older than telescopes, and it had many practical uses.

MCQ 2

B. The Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land hold well-documented Knowledge linking the Moon to the rising and falling of the tides, built up over thousands of years of observation.

MCQ 3

D. In the scientific account, the Moon's gravity pulls on the Earth's oceans, raising tidal bulges that we feel as high tides. It is not caused by the Moon's temperature or light, or by the Earth's distance from the Sun.

MCQ 4

A. When the Sun, the Earth and the Moon line up at new Moon and full Moon, their pulls add together and we get the largest tides, called spring tides. Neap tides are the smallest, at the quarter Moons.

MCQ 5

B. They are complementary ways of knowing. Both recognise a real, predictable link between the Moon and the tides, and both came from careful observation of the sky over a long time. It is not "myth versus fact", and they do not disagree about whether the Moon affects the tides.

Short Answer 1

Model answer: The Yolngu People of north-east Arnhem Land hold detailed Cultural Knowledge connecting the Moon to the tides. Living on Country beside the sea, they observed over many generations that the rising and falling of the tides matches the position and phase of the Moon. This Knowledge was developed over many thousands of years and passed on through oral tradition, story, song and Lore.

Short Answer 2

Model answer: In the scientific account, the Moon's gravity pulls on the Earth's oceans and raises tidal bulges, which we feel as high tides as the Earth rotates. The phase of the Moon tells us where the Moon is compared with the Sun. At new Moon and full Moon the Sun and Moon line up and their pulls add together, giving the largest tides (spring tides). At the quarter Moons the tides are smallest (neap tides). So the phase of the Moon is linked to the size of the tides.

Short Answer 3

Model answer: The two accounts are similar because both recognise a real, predictable link between the Moon's phase and the tides, and both were built from careful observation of the sky over a long time. They differ because the Yolngu Knowledge is held within Culture and passed on through story, song and Lore, while the scientific account is written down and explains the link using the idea of the Moon's gravity. Both can be seen as reliable because both come from patient, repeated observation, and both can be used to predict when high and low tides will come. They are complementary ways of knowing, not "myth versus fact".

Want help with First Astronomers?

Work through this topic 1-on-1 with an experienced HSC tutor.

Book a free session →